Skip to content
Lighting Aim
0
  1. Lighting Aim
  2. Lighting guides
  3. LED vs Halogen vs Incandescent: Which Bulb Is Best?

LED vs Halogen vs Incandescent: Which Bulb Is Best?

How the three bulb technologies compare on efficiency, light quality, heat, lifespan and availability.

  • Comparison
  • 4 min read
LED vs Halogen vs Incandescent: Which Bulb Is Best?

For almost every home use, LED is the best choice: it gives the same light for a fraction of the power, lasts far longer and comes in every colour temperature. Halogen and incandescent bulbs give excellent colour but waste most of their energy as heat, and they have been phased out for general lighting in many countries.

For a century, choosing a light bulb meant choosing a wattage. Then came halogen, compact fluorescent and finally LED, and the shelves became confusing. Today the choice is simpler than it looks, but it helps to understand how the technologies differ, especially when replacing old bulbs in existing fittings. This guide compares them. Bulb bases and shapes are covered in light bulb bases explained; the wider picture is in the home lighting guide.

How each one works

  • IncandescentA thin filament heats until it glows. Simple and warm, but most energy becomes heat.
  • HalogenAn improved filament bulb with halogen gas; brighter and longer-lasting than incandescent, still inefficient.
  • LEDSemiconductor chips produce light directly; electronics in the bulb or fitting control the current.

Comparison table

Feature Incandescent Halogen LED
Efficiency Very low Low High
Heat Very hot Very hot Warm at the base
Lifespan Short Short to medium Long
Colour rendering Excellent Excellent Good to excellent
Colour temperatures Warm only Warm only Full range
Dimming Simple Simple Needs compatible products

Efficiency and running cost

Efficiency is measured in lumens per watt. Filament bulbs turn only a small part of their power into light; LEDs turn much more. That is why an LED of under 10 W can replace an old 60 W bulb. Over its long life, an LED usually costs much less to run, even if it costs more to buy. Compare products by lumens rather than watts; see how many lumens do I need.

Light quality

Filament bulbs render colours almost perfectly and produce a warm, continuous light. Early LEDs were criticised for cold, harsh light, but good modern LEDs offer warm white and high colour rendering. Look for 2700 K for a filament-like colour and CRI 90 or above for colour quality; see colour temperature explained and CRI explained.

Heat

Halogen bulbs in particular run very hot, which matters in small enclosed fittings, near fabrics and in bathrooms. LEDs produce much less heat at the front, although their electronics need some ventilation, so fully enclosed fittings may shorten LED life unless the bulb is rated for them.

Dimming

Filament bulbs dim with almost any dimmer. LEDs need to be marked dimmable and used with a compatible dimmer; otherwise they may flicker or buzz. The dimmable LED guide explains how to avoid problems.

Replacing old bulbs

  1. Note the base (for example E27, E14, B22, GU10).
  2. Note the shape and size so it fits the fitting and shade.
  3. Check the lumens of the old bulb's equivalent rather than its wattage.
  4. Choose the colour temperature you want, usually 2700 K to match old bulbs.
  5. Check dimmability if the fitting is on a dimmer.

Availability

Many countries have restricted or phased out incandescent and most halogen bulbs for general lighting because of their low efficiency. Some special-purpose bulbs remain available. In practice, LED is now the standard choice for homes.

Replace filament and halogen bulbs with LEDs, matching base, shape and lumens, choosing warm white and high CRI where you want the old look, and checking dimmability where needed.

Frequently asked questions

Do LEDs really last longer?

Typically yes; rated lifetimes are much longer than filament bulbs, though heat and poor electronics can shorten them.

Are filament-style LEDs good?

They imitate the look of old bulbs with LED efficiency; check lumens and CRI.

What about compact fluorescent bulbs?

They have largely been replaced by LEDs, which start instantly and contain no mercury.

Part of the master guideThe Home Lighting Guide: Lumens, Colour and Layers

General information only. Mains wiring, new circuits and work in bathrooms should be carried out by a qualified electrician in line with local regulations. Always follow the product's installation instructions.

ShareWhatsAppPinterest